Congress Should Expose or Outlaw Astroturfers

Wed, 2009-08-19 16:21Jim Hoggan
Jim Hoggan's picture

Congress Should Expose or Outlaw Astroturfers

The venerable New York Times has reported the discovery of “More Fake Letters To Congress” by Bonner & Associates, the Astroturf specialists hired by Americans for Clean Coal Electricity (ACCE) to interfere with the vote on the Waxman-Markey bill.

As much as Bonner has tried to deny its involvement, the agency was clearly the source of forged letters, purporting to come from charitable organizations opposed to the climate bill. But then, Bonner’s record is well-recorded.

As William Greider described in his book, Who Will Tell the People, Bonner has operated a “boiler room” that featured “300 phone lines and a sophisticated computer system, resembling the phone banks employed in election campaigns. Articulate young people sit in little booths every day, dialing around America on a variety of public issues, searching for ‘white hat’ citizens who can be persuaded to endorse the political objectives of Mobil Oil, Dow Chemical, Citicorp, Ohio Bell, Miller Brewing, US Tobacco, the Chemical Manufacturers Association, the Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association and dozens of other clients.”

If Bonner’s clients are that desperate to have a voice on Capitol Hill, Congress should call a hearing, inquiring into just how much influence is being peddled through phony organizations and faked letters. The U.S. badly needs legislation that requires organizations like Bonner to be more transparent and accountable, to disclose their funding and to declare their purpose on every occasion.

Any such legislation will also have to come with significant penalties. It doesn’t seem that Bonner is bothered by whether this activity might already violate the standards of political integrity that are critical in a law-abiding democracy.


Previous Comments

Sounds like Bonner is for-profit agency. Many astroturf organizations are nonprofit, i.e., “charities” who dont list their donors while they advertise for the benefit of their donors. Further, the money slides through a net of astroturf foundations,societies, phoney science organizations, so that the source becomes more obscure. Even some religious committees have been paid, and then started preaching the gospel according to Exxon Mobile.
Do those who fund the ACCE get a tax break? Certainly, Heartland is a nonprofit who stopped revealing its donors about the time it began staging phoney “science” conferences.

I hope Bonner & all are charged with fraud. Maybe people think deception in the service of private industry is no crime. I am sick of lies.

And I hope Markey”s committee investigates more than specifically Bonner.

Faked science; faked graphs; faked data; faked memos; fake claims [straw man]; fake experts; faked grass-roots movements; faked consensus; faked claims of suppression: Is there anything about the denialists’ campaign apart from the lies that isn’t fake?

Where are the trolls when you want them?


Every good magician knows that the key to success is misdirecting the audience. You have to draw everyone’s attention away from your ultimate goal in order to perform the trick. Politics is no different, and one of the greatest misdirections in recent memory has been pulled off by the fossil fuel industry.

While most of the environmental movement was (rightfully) focusing attention on stopping the Keystone XL tar sands export pipeline from crossing over one of the most vital aquifers in the U.S., the dirty energy industry was quietly building a network of...

read more